I’m noticing that a lot of people don’t seem to be open to hearing nuance regarding CisHarm identities. To a point it’s very irritating.

I could fall under Cis or Trans harm. For several reasons.

Dropping my coping mechanism, I went through RAMCOA. I could technically fall under both Cis and Trans Nazi because I was programmed to be a Nazi as a child via RAMCOA. I still struggle, to this day, with intrusive thoughts and knee-jerk reactions towards things I don’t understand. I still, mentally, respond with hatred and fear. I didn’t ask to be like this, and I’m doing my best to recover. However, that doesn’t mean I’m suddenly not that. I’m recoverING, I’m not recoverED.

I’m still going through an active journey of self-improvement, but that doesn’t mean I don’t still respond as if I was never a Nazi. I have to take time to look at what I don’t understand and talk to people to understand. Sure, I’m slowly recovering. But I’m not recovered.

This same thing could apply to people like me who are programmed certain ways, such as people with Prince Programming, who were forced to sexually assault people, or even just recovering bigots, amongst a lot of other reasons one would identify as such. These are just a few reasons one may identify as CisBigot or CisRapist or CisNazi.

And this is completely disregarding cases like Conabuse relationships, as my partners and I have agreed to do horrible things to each other within our boundaries! I’m a CisStalker, because I stalk my partners with their consent, and have for years! They love that I do that! Similarly, my partners could fall under CisRapist because, with conabuse, they have done such to me, and I’m okay with that!

It’s not always meant in bad faith, but rather as a way towards recovery, or even as a coping mechanism for things they were forced into. CisHarmful people could be fully transitioned TransHarmful people.

CisHarmful is not the same thing as CisGender, and we need to stop acting like it is. Please, have nuance towards people! As long as there’s no non-consensual harm, I don’t care!

  • shiro
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    6 months ago

    well said. some of us resonate as well. the rqc on tumblr is way too discourse poisoned…

    • Yui KomoriOPM
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      6 months ago

      Absolutely. It’s so bad, it’s hard to even browse the Tumblr RQC because of all the discourse…